Are LTO Registering Three Wheelers Correctly?
- So why have LTO started registering Three Wheelers as Motorcycle with sidecar?
- A tricycle is a three wheeled bicycle.
- Are Bajaj RE and Piaggio Ape Motorcycles with Sidecars?
- The problem with registering the Bajaj RE and Piaggio Ape with sidecar
- Is a three wheeler legal when registered as Motorcycle with Sidecar?
- It is a mess
- How to tell the difference
LTO have started to register three wheelers such as the Bajaj RE and the Piaggio Ape as Motorcycle with sidecars. Is this the correct way of registering three wheelers?
When the Piaggio Ape and the Bajaj RE were first introduced to the Philippines LTO registered them as Non-Conventional Motorcycle and we believe that is the correct way to register them.
The Vienna Road Convention which the Philippines is a signatory to states:
“Motorcycle” means any two-wheeled vehicle, with or without a side-car, which is
equipped with a propelling engine. Contracting Parties may also treat as motorcycles in their
domestic legislation three-wheeled vehicles whose unladen mass does not exceed 400 kg. The term
“motorcycle” does not include mopeds, although Contracting Parties may, provided they make a
declaration to this effect in conformity with Article 54, paragraph 2, of this Convention, treat
mopeds as motorcycles for the purposes of the Convention;
That means that three wheelers such as the Bajaj RE, Piaggio Ape and TVS King should be regarded as motorbikes.
So why have LTO started registering Three Wheelers as Motorcycle with sidecar?
The problem has came about because of 2 reasons.
Problems with the owners getting franchises to use them as public utility vehicles.
Incorrect use of the word tricycle in the Philippines.
The problem with owners getting franchises should have been fixed by Local Government Unites (LGU) setting up franchises for three wheeled vehicles. Not by LTO changing the class to something they clearly are not.
The word tricycle has been incorrectly used instead of Motorcycle and Sidecar for many years in the Philippines and it is causing problems.
A tricycle is a three wheeled bicycle.
Cambridge English Dictionary
Tricycle – a small vehicle like a bicycle with two wheels at the back and one at the front, used especially by young children.
Under the Vienna Road Convention there is no class of vehicle called tricycle.
What does the senate regard as a tricycle?
Because of the incorrect use of the word tricycle in 2009 the Senate had to declare what was meant by tricycle and they made it very clear.
FOURTEENTH CONGRESS OF THE REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES S.B. 3289
A. TRICYCLE – means a motor vehicle composed of a motorcycle with not more
than two (2) cylinders of five hundred cubic centimetres (500cc) engine capacity
fitted with single-wheel side car designed to accommodate four (4) passengers only
including the driver.
Since then it has been pointed out in many documents of law that a tricycle is a motorcycle and sidecar.
The reason tricycles as they are known in the Philippines are not registered as a tricycle is simple. It is because they are not tricycles. They are in fact registered as Motorcycle with Sidecar the reason being that is the correct term and classification for them.
Are Bajaj RE and Piaggio Ape Motorcycles with Sidecars?
Again we will refer to the Cambridge English Dictionary
Sidecar – a small, one-wheeled vehicle attached to the side of a motorcycle to hold a passenger.
Neither the Bajaj RE or the Piaggio Ape have a small, one-wheeled vehicle attached to their side. So they are not with sidecar.
It cannot be correct to register them with sidecar for a simple reason, they do not have a sidecar.
The problem with registering the Bajaj RE and Piaggio Ape with sidecar
The first problem is safety. While both of them are very safe vehicles they could easily be turned into something that is not safe by adding a sidecar.
We are all very aware that some PUV drivers think it is a great idea to find ways to get as many people as possible in their vehicle. It is very possible that some of them might think it is a good idea to add a sidecar to their three wheeler.
You might think LTO and enforcers would not allow a sidecar being attached to a three wheeler. The truth is without passing new laws which takes time, there is nothing they could do to stop them.
The driver could just show his registration documents and say look LTO registered it with sidecar and that is what it has.
Please Please Please for your safety and the safety of others do not try adding a sidecar to a three wheeler. I can promise you it will handle badly and would not be safe.
We have searched on Google and can’t find anything about a Bajaj RE having a sidecar fitted, probably because it would be illegal in every other country. However registering them with sidecar has given the green light to anyone stupid enough to try it.
Is a three wheeler legal when registered as Motorcycle with Sidecar?
This is debatable and without ploughing through loads of laws we think it is probably not legal to drive. The reason being it is registered as a Motorcycle with Sidecar but there is no sidecar.
I have seen videos where MMDA have ticketed motorbikes because they were registered as Motorcycle with Sidecar but they had detached the sidecar and were using them just as motorbikes.
It seems it maybe regarded as illegal to drive a motorcycle that is registered as having a sidecar, without the sidecar attached.
The problem seems to be that a motorcycle with sidecar has a yellow plate and a Motorcycle without Sidecar has a white plate. Which means if you detach the sidecar from a motorcycle and sidecar it then has the wrong plates so you are likely to get stopped.
If they register a three wheeler as motorcycle with sidecar we presume that when LTO finally gets round to issuing plates they will issue a yellow plate to match the registration.
Here is the problem it has no sidecar so you have the wrong plates. So as soon as you put plates on a three wheeler that is registered as a three wheeler an enforcer could stop you for having the wrong plates.
It is a mess
Yes it sounds a mess, the reason being it is a mess. Allegedly shortcuts have been taken to solve a problem without a lot of thought going into what problems they might create.
What is very clear is Bajaj RE, Piaggio Ape and TVS King do not have sidecars and so surely it can not be correct to register them as Motorcycle with Sidecar.
We hate to think how you would stand if you have an accident in a three wheeler registered as a Motorcycle with Sidecar. We are very aware how some insurance companies like to find ways not to pay out. In this case it is very possible they will refuse to pay because you have removed the sidecar you never had.
All the above is just based on our thoughts and what terms mean in the English language. As the law are written in English we have presumed that the correct English meaning for words is the correct use of them.
How to tell the difference
It really is simple to tell the difference.
If you look at the photo below we have clearly labeled each one for people that get confused. They would not call a 4 wheeled car, a jeepney and a kids go-kart Quads just because they all have 4 wheels. So why do people in the Philippines presume everything with 3 wheels is a tricycle?
Registering Three Wheelers was done correctly when they first arrived in the Philippines so why have they changed it to something it is not.